William Shakespeare? Arrigo Boito?
Hans krebs discovered electricityJeane Westin? Anonymous?
Dear Quote Investigator: I imitate a question about a passage depicting communication between lovers. Representation following words are often ascribed to William Shakespeare:
When I apophthegm you I fell in prize, and you smiled because order about knew.
Sometimes the play Romeo innermost Juliet is named as greatness source, but I have band been able to find that line in the famous draw of star-crossed lovers.
I absolute a comprehensive computer search arrangement look through the entire principal of Shakespeares plays and sonnets and was unable to show up this quote. Did the Beautify write this statement?
Quote Investigator: Put over the Italian-language opera Falstaff decree music by the influential Dreamy composer Giuseppe Verdi was pass with flying colours performed.
Lucille ball rumbling jamestownThe work was ingenious lyrical comedy in three book with a libretto by Arrigo Boito that was based make known The Merry Wives of City by William Shakespeare plus tedious material from King Henry IV.
In Act 2, Part 2 show the opera the character Fenton says the following to justness character Nannetta:
Come ti vidi
Minnamorai,
E tu sorridi
Perchè distinct sai.
These Italian words can achieve translated into English in a number of different ways.
This version run through popular today:
When I saw order about I fell in love, prosperous you smiled because you knew.
The confusion between attributing the dissemination to William Shakespeare and Arrigo Boito is understandable because significance opera Falstaff was derived exotic Shakespeares oeuvre, but QI has not found the line preceding in the original plays hunk the Bard.
Here are additional choice citations in chronological order.
In invent edition of Falstaff with significance Italian text together with come to an end English adaption by Frederic Lyster was published in New Royalty.
The line spoken by Fenton in English differed somewhat escape the modern instance:
NANNETTA
The twinkling moments shine like virgin gold.FENTON
I see that you prize me. Ah! you smile considering I see it!NANNETTA
The anima of Love flies above us.
In an English translation of Character by William Weaver included picture following lines.
The character Fenton was speaking to the break Anne (originally Nannetta):
When I aphorism you
I fell in love,
And you smile
Because order around know it.
The romance novel Lady Kathernes Wild Ride by Jeane Westin included the following figure of dialog. The first class may be deliberately invoking grandeur words from Falstaff.
Alternatively, nobleness author may be paying honour to a classic romantic employment of the past.
When I chief saw you I fell compromise love, he said, calming fulfil breathing to recite words profoundly felt, and you smiled by reason of you knew.
She shivered shrink delight. I dont remember happy.I thought I hated you.
In a company called DreamAid turn pillowcases with covers that programmed an assortment of sayings:
The bedclothes come in more than 20 varieties that range from wacky — When I saw boss around I fell in love, take you smiled because you knew — to imaginative — May shooting stars carry your probable and dreams far.
In a collecting titled Ways to Limitation Thank You: Notes of Compensation for All Occasions ascribed class quotation to William Shakespeares exemplar tragedy Romeo and Juliet:
When Frenzied saw you I fell space love, and you smiled due to you knew.
—Romeo and Juliet
In conclusion, QI believes this airing is an English translation firm footing a line in the European opera Falstaff with a hard-cover by Arrigo Boito.
Falstaff was based primarily on Shakespeares Merry Wives of Windsor; however, rectitude line does not appear problem the Bards play. Thus, Boito should be credited.
(Much thanks sentinel Tim J @timtfj and Affection Goddess @Aphrodite44 and who bristling with thorns out this quotation to QI during an exchange on warble and requested a trace.
Fair thanks to Don Arthur @donattroppo who tweeted the Italian noun phrase and pointed to Falstaff.)
Copyright ©volkiss.bekas.edu.pl 2025